Meet the cast of 'All In: Comedy About Love by Simon Rich' on Broadway

Learn more about the new play’s stars including John Mulaney, Renée Elise Goldsberry, Lin-Manuel Miranda, Jimmy Fallon, Aidy Bryant, Richard Kind, and more.

Gillian Russo
Gillian Russo

Call it a funny valentine! The new play All In: Comedy About Love by Simon Rich, running from December 11 to February 16 at the Hudson Theatre, promises to be that kind of theatrical sampler. It’s also the sort whose rotating cast is stacked with stars who are Tony Award, Emmy Award, and Pulitzer Prize winners. Who wouldn't love that?

Authored by Emmy-nominated Saturday Night Live writer Simon Rich, who adapted the show from his collection of short stories, All In features bite-sized vignettes about sex, marriage, dating, and romance-gone-wrong. And there’s music. Stephin Merritt of The Magnetic Fields wrote the songs, and the married duo The Bengsons performs them in their Broadway debut.

There are 14 total cast members, but each performance of All In only features four of them. Get to know more about who’s in the play, and when, below. No funny business — just stars in chronological order of their performance dates.

Check back for information on All In: Comedy About Love by Simon Rich tickets on New York Theatre Guide.

john mulaney-1200x600-NYTG

John Mulaney

A celebrated, sharp-witted comedian, John Mulaney launched his career as a writer on Saturday Night Live, where he co-created the iconic character Stefon. In 2016, Mulaney made his Broadway debut in Oh, Hello with Nick Kroll.

He’s best known, however, for his stand-up specials, including Kid Gorgeous and Baby J, which both won Emmy Awards for writing. Plus, listen up for his voice acting in Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse and Big Mouth.

All In performance dates: December 11 - January 12

fred armisen-1200x600-NYTG

Fred Armisen

Known as a Saturday Night Live cast member from 2002 to 2013, Fred Armisen makes his Broadway debut in All In. Besides co-creating and starring in Portlandia, Documentary Now!, and Moonbase 8, he’s popped up as a guest star on 30 Rock, Parks and Recreation, Brooklyn Nine-Nine, and more sitcoms over the years. For a decade beginning in 2014, he led The Late Night with Seth Meyers house band.

All In performance dates: December 11 - January 12

renee elise goldsberry-1200x600-NYTG

Renée Elise Goldsberry

Work! Renée Elise Goldsberry is widely recognized for originating the role of Angelica Schuyler in Hamilton, earning Tony and Grammy Awards. Her other notable stage credits include Mimi in Rent, Silvia in The Two Gentlemen of Verona, and Nettie in the first Broadway run of The Color Purple. Goldsberry’s screen credits include Girls5eva, One Life to Live, and The Good Wife.

All In performance dates: December 11-30

richard kind-1200x600-NYTG

Richard Kind

A Tony nominee in 2013 for his supporting role in The Big Knife, Richard Kind’s Broadway career stretches from his 2000 debut in the play The Tale of the Allergist’s Wife to his most recent role in the 2019 revival of the musical Kiss Me, Kate. On television, Kind showed off his comedic timing in Spin City, Curb Your Enthusiasm, Mad About You, and Only Murders in the Building. He’s also voiced characters in A Bug’s Life and Inside Out.

All In performance dates: December 11 - January 12

chloe fineman-1200x600-NYTG

Chloe Fineman

Since 2019, Chloe Fineman has done standout work on Saturday Night Live, becoming famous for her celebrity impressions. In addition to voicing characters in Big Mouth, Despicable Me 4, and The Simpsons, Fineman has appeared in the films White Noise and Babylon.

All In performance dates: January 2-12

lin manuel miranda-1200x600-NYTG

Lin-Manuel Miranda

Famous for creating and starring in the groundbreaking musical Hamilton, which won a Pulitzer, a Grammy, and 11 Tonys including Best Musical, Lin-Manuel Miranda has firmly notched his place in theatre history. He also won a Tony and Grammy for writing the songs for his earlier musical, In the Heights. In 2021, Miranda won a Special Tony Award as a co-founder of the hip-hop comedy troupe Freestyle Love Supreme.

Miranda appeared on screen in Mary Poppins Returns; wrote songs for Disney’s Encanto, Moana, and Vivo, and directed the Oscar-nominated movie musical tick, tick... BOOM!

All In performance dates: January 14 - February 16

aidy bryant-1200x600-NYTG

Aidy Bryant

An Emmy-nominated comedian and actress who cracked up audiences as a Saturday Night Live cast member from 2012-22, Aidy Bryant makes her Broadway debut in All In. She also co-produced, co-wrote, and starred in the Hulu series Shrill.

All In performance dates: January 14 - February 2

andrew rannells-1200x600-NYTG

Andrew Rannells

A Tony nominee for The Book of Mormon and Falsettos, Andrew Rannells reliably makes a big impression on stage. He’s also known for Gutenberg! The Musical!, The Boys in the Band, Hamilton, and Hedwig and the Angry Inch.

Rannells’s notable TV credits include Girls, The New Normal, Black Monday, and voice acting in Big Mouth. He also played a key role in the movie version of the Broadway show The Prom.

All In performance dates: January 14-26

sam richardson-1200x600-NYTG

Sam Richardson

An Emmy winner for his guest performance on Ted Lasso and a well-known cast member of the spiky political comedy Veep, Sam Richardson makes his Broadway debut in All In. Other notable TV credits include Detroiters, I Think You Should Leave with Tim Robinson, The Afterparty, and Velma.

All In performance dates: January 14 - February 2

jimmy fallon-1200x600-NYTG

Jimmy Fallon

A newcomer to the Broadway stage, Jimmy Fallon is no stranger to late-night television. He has hosted The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon since 2014, a coveted role he took on after hosting Late Night with Jimmy Fallon from 2009-2014. Previously, Fallon was a cast member of Saturday Night Live from 1998-2004. He’s also appeared in the movies Taxi and Fever Pitch.

All In performance dates: January 28 - February 2

david cross-1200x600-NYTG

David Cross

A comedian, actor, and writer, David Cross is known for acting up as Tobias Fünke on Arrested Development and co-creating Mr. Show with Bob and David. Cross has appeared in films like Alvin and the Chipmunks and Scary Movie 2, and he voiced characters in Family Guy. He makes his Broadway debut in All In.

All In performance dates: February 4-9

tim meadows-1200x600-NYTG

Tim Meadows

A familiar face thanks to his long run on Saturday Night Live from 1991-2000, Tim Meadows is also well-known for playing a school principal in the movie Mean Girls. He reprising the role in Mean Girls 2 and the 2024 stage-to-screen adaptation of the Mean Girls Broadway musical. He makes his Broadway debut in All In.

All In performance dates: February 4-16

annaleigh ashford-1200x600-NYTG

Annaleigh Ashford

A Tony Award winner for You Can’t Take It with You and a nominee for Sweeney Todd and Kinky Boots, Annaleigh Ashford’s other notable stage credits include Sunday in the Park with George and Wicked. She’s also in her comfort zone on screen, where she showed off her flair for comedy and drama in Masters of Sex, Impeachment: American Crime Story, and B Positive.

All In performance dates: February 4-16

hank azaria-1200x600-NYTG

Hank Azaria

An Emmy-winning actor known for voicing numerous characters on The Simpsons, Hank Azaria had key roles in the TV series Mad About You and Ray Donovan. On Broadway, Azaria received a Tony nod for his role in Spamalot and appeared in the drama The Farnsworth Invention. His film credits include Godzilla, Along Came Polly, and The Birdcage.

All In performance dates: February 11-16

Check back for information on All In: Comedy About Love by Simon Rich tickets on New York Theatre Guide.

Visit our fall preview page to learn more about all fall 2024 Broadway shows and discover more content.

Photo credit: The Broadway cast of All In. (Photos courtesy of production)

Originally published on

Subscribe to our newsletter to unlock exclusive New York theatre updates!

  • Get early access to Broadway's newest shows
  • Access to exclusive deals and promotions
  • Stay in the know about top shows and news on Broadway
  • Get updates on shows that are important to you

You can unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy