NYTG Logo
Five people gathered around a table in a home setting, appearing to have a serious discussion.

Photo credit: Al'Jaleel McGhee, Liza Colón-Zayas, Francis Guinan, K. Todd Freeman, and Adrian Martinez in Downstate on Broadway. (Photo by Emilio Madrid)

'Downstate' Broadway review — where does horridness end and humanity begin?

Read our review of Downstate, the Broadway-premiere production of Bruce Norris's dark dramedy that won multiple awards for its 2022 Off-Broadway premiere.

Summary

  • Downstate is set at a group home for child sex offenders, where one man arrives to confront his former abuser decades later
  • Playwright Bruce Norris's play contains transgressive dark comedy and prompts debate about the acceptable extents of justice, punishment, forgiveness, sympathy, and humanity
  • The show is recommended for anyone who wants to see a show that sparks conversation, anyone who works in the justice system, or appreciators of plays like Here There Are Blueberries
  • Downstate has an age requirement of 17+ due to frank discussions of sex abuse and pedophilia
Gillian Russo
Gillian Russo

Deep into Act 2 of Bruce Norris's twisted, rapturous Downstate on Broadway, the elderly Fred (Francis Guinan) loses control of his motorized wheelchair and nearly crashes into his kitchen table. He's mid-conversation with the 40something Andy (Thomas Sadoski), who instinctively reaches for Fred's shoulder to stop him, help him. It's a charged contact. Firstly, it's one of the few times in Downstate where we see one character touch another non-aggressively — that is, not to attack or arrest. Secondly, the last time Fred and Andy touched, Andy was 12, Fred was his piano teacher, and... well, you fill in the blank. Fred and his three roommates, all formerly incarcerated child sex offenders sharing a downstate Illinois group home, are people Andy — and we — would rather keep at arm's length.

But for two and a half hours, Norris won't let us. Quite the opposite: He crams us into the few pockets of silence between overlapping arguments, into the limited headroom between the beige carpet and the slanted ceiling that looks all but ready to close in on those under it. (The effectively cheerless set design is by Scott Pask.) Visually and aurally, director Joe Mantello's production is taut and overwhelming and suffocating, and that's the point.

Early on, parole officer Ivy (The Bear's Liza Colón-Zayas) tells the men the nearest bus stop and the local grocery store are newly off limits due to their proximity to a school, despite a six-lane highway separating the locales. All four roommates feel they've served their time but are now simply in a different prison, where the range of acceptable space for them to occupy is basically nonexistent. That goes for beyond the house — as suggested by the seemingly endless black wall behind the comparatively tiny building — and even inside it — as shown by the shoddily boarded-up window a displeased neighbor had shot at. According to the abrasive, remorseless Dee (K. Todd Freeman, giving a standout performance among a uniformly strong ensemble), they get that kind of thing a lot.

Can we sympathize? Or at least listen? Fred, Dee, Gio (Al'Jaleel McGhee), and Felix (Adrian Martinez) can't fight the system, so they — particularly Dee and Gio — resort to fighting each other instead. Norris dares to infuse Downstate with genuine comedy as he teases out this Odd Couple-like dynamic between the men, with their petty bickering as well as their tacit understandings of each other's tiniest personal quirks and boundaries. It's somewhat of an irony, considering how they've all crossed one of the biggest boundaries there is. They know that — to varying extents; no one's entirely repentant here — and seem to figure they can at least try to get right in small ways: Felix turns to his Bible, Dee plays house mother, Gio gets a job at Staples, Fred retreats into a docile aw-shucks demeanor. (Norris, in one of his many devilish strokes, named the character after Mr. Rogers.)

So when Andy tenderly touches Fred in the middle of berating him for his abuse and its lasting consequences, it forces a reckoning — not just for him, but for anyone with a neat mental image of the perfect victim, of the bestial perpetrator, of the idea that either of these people are anything but human, in all the mess that entails, even though their wrongs are not created equal. As our stomachs churn more and more at the mere thought of this, Norris reminds us it's not just us who can't reconcile existing alongside these perpetrators. They'd rather not share a world with each other, either. Looks like we all have something in common.

17 downstate broadway-1200x600-NYTG

Downstate summary

In downstate Illinois, four men — doddering pianist Fred, sharp-tongued dancer Dee, motormouthed retail worker Gio, and solitary father Felix — share a group home after serving time as child sex offenders. Reluctant roommates united only by their criminal history and a shrinking radius they're allowed to occupy, the quartet's tense daily lives are blown open with the arrival of the 40something Andy to confront Fred, his former abuser. The play probes thorny questions about the line between perpetrator and victim, the extent of justice, and how much humanity we can, and should, to extend to people who've done the unthinkable.

Downstate premiered at Chicago's Steppenwolf Theatre Company in 2018, in London in 2019, and off Broadway in 2022, winning New York Drama Critics' Circle, Outer Critics Circle, and Obie Awards for playwriting. Francis Guinan and K. Todd Freeman (who received multiple performance awards) have appeared in all four of these iterations of Downstate, including on Broadway.

What to expect at Downstate

Downstate runs 2 and a half hours, including an intermission. The production has an age requirement of 17+, and it contains strong language and an ableist slur, staged violence, frank discussions of pedophilia, and descriptions of sex acts. (No sex or sex abuse is staged.) The play also addresses topics including terminal illness, suicide, and death.

All that is to say, it's not for the faint of heart and is likely to be emotionally disturbing no matter your experience with Norris's subject matter. And yet, although it's a show I don't particularly want to see again, Downstate is the kind of show at which repeat viewings would spark deeper thought about its complex debates and uncover new intricacies of the ensemble's layered performances. At one point, Andy falls into his old instinct to seek Fred's approval and support and quickly recoils at doing so. Downstate itself has a similarly repulsive yet undeniable pull.

18 downstate broadway-1200x600-NYTG

What audiences are saying about Downstate

As of writing, Downstate on Broadway has a 91% audience approval rating on the review aggregator Show-Score. Responses have been mostly positive, with many theatregoers finding they enjoyed it in spite of themselves and their preconceptions. Whether any given person likes it or not, though, one thing's for certain: Downstate gets people talking.

  • "A surprisingly funny and deeply affecting play, featuring some of the most extraordinary performances I've witnessed on a Broadway stage. An astonishing balance of humor, humanity, and emotional complexity." - Show-Score user Kristian Monday
  • "I was questioning myself as I sat there and felt bad for men who have done terrible things. Mercy is a funny thing. Acting was tremendous esp the actor who played Dee. Wow!!!!!" - Show-Score user Ashley G
  • "It is like an onion that reveals aspects of each character over the course of the play. It caused a great amount of discussion afterwards." - Show-Score user Lynn Manuell
  • "Great acting. Not for everyone. I thought it was one of the best plays that year when I first saw it in Playwrights Horizon. I didn't notice much changes from then to broadway." - Show-Score user Theresa 2007

Read more audience reviews of Downstate on Show-Score.

Who should see Downstate

  • Anyone working in the legal or corrections fields may be interested by Downstate's exploration of the justice system, including its flaws and limits.
  • Everyone should see K. Todd Freeman deliver a masterclass of a performance as Dee, whose off-putting wisecracks and lack of remorse for his crimes belie a much more complicated interior.
  • Downstate might interest appreciators of another Broadway show two blocks north: Here There Are Blueberries, which also confronts audiences with the humanity of people who've committed horrid atrocities.

Learn more about Downstate on Broadway

Bruce Norris doesn't let anyone off the hook in Downstate, on stage or off. It's what makes the play gut-wrenching, horrifying, difficult — and excellent.

Photo credit: Downstate on Broadway. (Photos by Emilio Madrid)

Frequently asked questions

Where is Downstate playing?

Downstate is playing at Booth Theatre. The theatre is located at 222 West 45th Street, New York, 10036.

How much do tickets cost for Downstate?

Tickets for Downstate start at $75.

What's the age recommendation for Downstate?

The recommended age for Downstate is Ages 17+..

How do you book tickets for Downstate?

Book tickets for Downstate on New York Theatre Guide.

Is Downstate on Broadway or Off-Broadway?

Downstate is playing Broadway.

Is Downstate accessible?

Wheelchair seating in the Orchestra only, assisted listening devices. No elevators or escalators.

How long is Downstate running?

Downstate currently has tickets available through 10 January 2027. Check calendar for availability.

Who is in the cast of Downstate?

The cast of Downstate includes K. Todd Freeman, Francis Guinan, Al'Jaleel McGhee, Adrian Martinez, Liza Colón-Zayas, Thomas Sadoski, Cassie Beck, and Ivy Wolk.

Who directed Downstate?

Downstate is directed by Joe Mantello.

Who wrote Downstate?

Downstate was written by Bruce Norris.

Originally published on

Subscribe to our newsletter to unlock exclusive New York theatre updates!

  • Get early access to Broadway's newest shows
  • Access to exclusive deals and promotions
  • Stay in the know about top shows and news on Broadway
  • Get updates on shows that are important to you

You can unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy